Joker borrows a famous name and very little else from the comics it's nominally based on. Todd Phillips builds a 1970s-style character study around Arthur Fleck, a mentally ill aspiring comedian ground down by a city that has no use for him, and the film is far more interested in social decay than in supervillain mythology.
Joaquin Phoenix's physical performance — the emaciated frame, the disturbing forced-laugh tic caused by a neurological condition — carries almost the entire film, and his dance down the Bronx stairwell after fully embracing the Joker persona is the closest thing the film has to a triumphant moment, deliberately uncomfortable to watch as triumph.
The film's politics are messier than its craft. It gestures at wealth inequality and a failing mental health system as explanations for Arthur's violence without fully committing to an argument about either, which leaves the film's back half feeling more interested in mood than meaning.
Where the film succeeds most is in its cinematography and score — Hildur Guðnadóttir's cello-driven music turns Arthur's unraveling into something operatic, and Lawrence Sher's grimy, garbage-strewn Gotham gives the film a texture closer to Scorsese than to a comic book adaptation.
Sources & further reading
- IMDb listing for Joker
- Wikipedia entry for Joker
- Official trailer credited to its distributor above; release details cross-checked at time of writing.
Stronger as mood and performance than as coherent argument. Phoenix commits completely to a character the script doesn't always know what to do with.