Review · Crime Epic · 2023

Killers of the Flower Moon

ADM 8/10 Dir. Martin Scorsese 206 min No major spoilers

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Apple TV

At 206 minutes, Killers of the Flower Moon demands a genuine commitment, and Scorsese uses every one of those minutes to build a slow, methodical portrait of complicity rather than a conventional crime thriller. The film follows the systematic murder of wealthy Osage Nation members in 1920s Oklahoma, and its most unsettling choice is centering the story on Ernest Burkhart, a man complicit in the murder of his own wife's family, rather than on a detective solving the case from the outside.

Lily Gladstone's Mollie is the film's moral and emotional core, playing a woman whose intelligence and quiet dignity are never in question even as the men around her, including her own husband, slowly poison her. Her performance works largely through restraint — small, devastating reactions rather than big speeches — and it's the reason the film's back half, as Mollie's health deteriorates, carries the weight it does.

Leonardo DiCaprio's Ernest is a genuinely difficult character to watch, a man weak and greedy enough to participate in the extermination of his own family for money, and DiCaprio plays him without a shred of the charisma he usually brings to morally compromised roles. Robert De Niro's William Hale, the town's outwardly benevolent patriarch orchestrating the murders, is chilling precisely because he never raises his voice.

The film's final act, a courtroom-adjacent framing device involving a radio broadcast, has drawn some criticism as a directorial indulgence, but it also serves as Scorsese's own acknowledgment that this story has too often been told by outsiders looking in, including, implicitly, himself.

Sources & further reading

ADM 8/10

206 minutes and not a wasted one. Gladstone's restraint carries scenes that a louder performance would have flattened.