Review · Southern Gothic Horror · 2025

Sinners

ADM 9/10 Dir. Ryan Coogler 137 min Light spoilers, marked

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Warner Bros. Pictures

Nobody in my group chat told me Sinners was a vampire movie before I saw it, and I think that was the right call, so I'll try to extend the same courtesy here for the first hour. What I'll say is that Ryan Coogler spends that first hour as a note-perfect period drama about twin brothers opening a juke joint in the Jim Crow South, so committed to the music and the dialogue and the specific feel of that world that I'd genuinely forgotten the marketing had promised me a horror film by the time the genre elements arrive.

Michael B. Jordan plays both twins, and I want to note I never once got them confused, which is a small technical thing but matters — Smoke and Stack are differentiated through posture and rhythm rather than any obvious costume trick. The long, patient setup of their business and their community turns out to matter enormously once the threat arrives, because by then I actually cared who might not survive the night.

The best horror metaphors don't announce themselves, and this one doesn't — a predator offering immortality and belonging in exchange for identity reads, unmistakably, as a story about what a musical tradition has had to survive being absorbed by.

Mild spoiler: there's a sequence where the vampire Remmick and his newly turned followers perform outside the juke joint, using music as a lure rather than a weapon, and it's the scene I keep coming back to. It makes the pitch for assimilation sound genuinely, uncomfortably beautiful before the film shows you the cost, and I caught myself half-swaying to it before catching myself.

The back half trades some of that first hour's patience for straightforward siege-horror beats, and I'll admit I missed the slower rhythm a little once things sped up. Whether that reads as a satisfying escalation or a step down depends on what you wanted going in — I wanted both movies this film is trying to be, and mostly got them, just not always in equal measure.

Sources & further reading

ADM 9/10

Spends an hour convincing you it's a period drama before showing its hand, and the reveal feels less like a twist than an argument the film was building the whole time.