Review · Tragicomedy · 2022

The Banshees of Inisherin

ADM 9/10 Dir. Martin McDonagh 114 min No major spoilers

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Searchlight Pictures

The premise of The Banshees of Inisherin is almost absurdly small: an aging man on a remote Irish island decides, with no real explanation, that he no longer likes his lifelong best friend, and refuses to speak to him again. What Martin McDonagh builds from that premise is a film that starts as a wry comedy of manners and ends somewhere much darker and stranger.

Colin Farrell's Pádraic gives one of the best performances of his career, playing a fundamentally decent, simple man whose entire identity is quietly destroyed by a rejection he can't process or accept. His confusion curdles slowly into something closer to obsession, and Farrell plays every stage of that decline with a rawness that never tips into melodrama.

Brendan Gleeson's Colm, the friend doing the rejecting, is given just enough motivation — a sudden, panicked awareness of his own mortality and a desire to spend his remaining years on something that outlasts him — to make his cruelty comprehensible without making it forgivable. The film's escalating stakes, as Colm threatens increasingly drastic measures to enforce the breakup, turn what began as a small-town squabble into something closer to a fable about stubbornness and grief.

Kerry Condon, as Pádraic's sister Siobhán, gives the film its clearest voice of reason, and her own quiet decision to leave the island entirely by the film's end reads as the only genuinely sane response to the pettiness closing in around her. The Irish Civil War rumbling in the background throughout, audible as distant cannon fire the characters largely ignore, becomes the film's clearest metaphor: small, personal feuds mirroring a larger, national one.

Sources & further reading

ADM 9/10

What starts as a small-town squabble escalates into something closer to a fable about stubbornness and grief. Funny until it very deliberately stops being funny.