Review · Detective Noir · 2022

The Batman

ADM 8/10 Dir. Matt Reeves 176 min No major spoilers

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Warner Bros. Pictures

Three minutes into The Batman, I turned to whoever I'd dragged to the 9:40 show and whispered "this is not what I expected," and got shushed, fairly. Matt Reeves opens on a voiceover that makes clear immediately this isn't the origin-story-again version of the character — no dead parents in an alley, no billionaire playboy front. Just a man narrating his own patrol log like he's already tired.

Robert Pattinson's Bruce Wayne is visibly, uncomfortably broken in a way I don't think the marketing sold very well. He's more at home skulking around in eyeliner than at any public event, and the film treats that as a problem to be solved rather than a cool character trait — this is someone who hasn't worked out how to be a person yet, only how to be a weapon, and Pattinson plays that with almost no charisma at all, which I mean as a compliment.

What actually won me over was the mystery structure. The Riddler's ciphers and greeting-card murders give Batman an honest case to work rather than a villain to simply punch at the end, and Paul Dano's performance is unsettling in a way I wasn't braced for — he's clearly modeled on a domestic radicalization pipeline more than a cartoon supervillain, and there's a scene where he calmly explains his grievance direct to camera that stuck with me longer than any of the action beats did.

This is the first live-action Batman film in years where solving the mystery, not throwing the punch, is the thing the movie actually cares about.

My one real complaint: at 176 minutes, I felt the runtime. Somewhere around the flood sequence in the final act, I checked how much time was left, which is never a good sign. A tighter last forty minutes would have pushed this from "strong" to something I'd rewatch more casually — as it stands, it's a film I respect more than I reach for.

Sources & further reading

ADM 8/10

Runs long and the back third sags under its own plotting, but this is the first live-action take on the character where solving the mystery actually matters more than the punch.