Review · Superhero Crime Thriller · 2008

The Dark Knight

ADM 9/10 Dir. Christopher Nolan 152 min Light spoilers, marked

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Warner Bros. Pictures

The clearest sign of how good The Dark Knight still is: it barely plays like a comic book movie. Nolan builds it as a crime epic first, with a costumed vigilante as one piece of a much larger machine, and the film's best scenes — a bank heist, an interrogation, a hospital detonation — would work in a film with no capes at all.

Heath Ledger's Joker is the reason this film is still discussed in the present tense. What makes the performance hold up isn't the makeup or the voice, it's the total absence of an origin story or a motive the film ever fully explains. He tells two different stories about his scars in two different scenes, and the film never resolves which is true, because the point is that neither matters. He's chaos with a philosophy, and Ledger commits to it without a single wink to the camera.

Mild spoiler: the film's ending, in which Batman takes the blame for Harvey Dent's crimes to preserve Gotham's faith in its white knight, is a more morally uncomfortable note than most blockbusters would risk. It's a story about a lie a city needs to keep functioning, and Nolan doesn't pretend that's a clean or comfortable outcome.

Aaron Eckhart's Harvey Dent deserves more credit than he usually gets; his fall from idealist to Two-Face is genuinely tragic rather than just a plot mechanism, largely because the film spends real time on who he is before the acid hits.

Sources & further reading

ADM 9/10

Barely plays like a comic book movie, and that's exactly why it's held up. Ledger's Joker still doesn't need an origin story to be the most unsettling thing on screen.