Review · Music Drama · 2014

Whiplash

ADM 9/10 Dir. Damien Chazelle 106 min No major spoilers

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Sony Pictures Classics

I've played drums, badly, since I was a teenager, which means I went into Whiplash assuming I'd have some special appreciation for the practice-room scenes. Instead I spent most of the film with my shoulders somewhere near my ears — Chazelle shoots a drum lesson with the tension most directors save for a hostage situation, and by the time blood is actually on the cymbals, I'd forgotten this was ostensibly a movie about jazz.

J.K. Simmons' Fletcher is the reason. I'd heard "terrifying teacher" going in and expected a cartoon; what I got was worse, because he's frequently, believably right about talent and mediocrity, and that's what makes his cruelty so hard to just write off. There's a moment where he calmly explains why "good job" is the most dangerous phrase in the English language, and against my better judgment, part of me nodded along before catching myself.

The real question the film is asking isn't whether Fletcher is a monster. It's whether the greatness he produces is worth what he destroys to get it — and Chazelle refuses to answer that cleanly, which is more than I expected from a film this tightly plotted.

Miles Teller's Andrew gets a real arc underneath the drumming — a young man quietly sacrificing a girlfriend, his family dinners, arguably his own mental health for a shot at being one of the greats — and the film's climactic extended solo is genuinely the tensest ten minutes I've sat through in a theater in years. I caught myself holding my breath, actually holding it, during the final cymbal crash, and only noticed when I exhaled after the cut to black. At a lean 106 minutes, this is a film that doesn't waste a second of your attention.

Sources & further reading

ADM 9/10

106 minutes and it doesn't waste a second of your attention. The final drum solo is the tensest ten minutes I've sat through in a theater in years.