It shouldn't work as well as it does: a film about the procedural mechanics of electing a new pope, confined almost entirely to the Vatican's locked halls, staged with the tension of a political thriller. But Conclave commits fully to treating Church politics as exactly that — politics, with all the ambition, factionalism, and quiet betrayal that word implies.
Ralph Fiennes' Cardinal Lawrence, tasked with overseeing the election while nursing his own crisis of faith, anchors the film with a performance built almost entirely on watchfulness — a man whose job requires him to read every room for hidden motive while trying to suppress his own. It's a quieter register than Fiennes often plays, and it suits the film's hushed, procedural tone.
Edward Berger, coming off All Quiet on the Western Front, shoots the Sistine Chapel and the cardinals' cramped dormitories with a clinical, almost horror-adjacent visual language — smoke signals, whispered alliances in hallways, ballots burned in silence — that makes an election with no violence feel as tense as a thriller with plenty.
The film's late twist regarding one candidate's concealed medical condition has drawn some criticism as overly convenient plotting, and it does arrive with more mechanical neatness than the film's otherwise patient character work. It's a minor wobble in an otherwise tightly controlled film.
Sources & further reading
- IMDb listing for Conclave
- Wikipedia entry for Conclave
- Official trailer credited to its distributor above; release details cross-checked at time of writing.
Nobody throws a punch in this film and it's still tenser than most action movies released the same year. Fiennes carries a hushed, procedural thriller about ambition in vestments.