I went to Past Lives expecting to be bored, honestly — the premise, childhood sweethearts reunited decades later for one week in New York, sounded like exactly the kind of quiet festival drama I usually admire more than enjoy. I was wrong within the first ten minutes, and wrong in a way that had nothing to do with plot, because almost nothing happens in this film that a more conventional script wouldn't turn into a crisis.
Greta Lee's Nora is the reason it works. She made the right call, by every practical measure, leaving Korea and later marrying her American husband — and the film never once suggests otherwise. What it sits with instead is the specific, low-grade ache of a life she didn't live running parallel to the one she did, which Celine Song refuses to frame as regret. I kept waiting for the film to punish Nora for that ambiguity, the way most romances would, and it never does.
I want to single out John Magaro's Arthur, Nora's husband, because he could so easily have been written as the obstacle or the consolation prize. Instead the film is generous toward him in a way I found almost moving on its own — there's a scene where he admits, half-joking and half not, that he's afraid of being the "boring option" in someone else's love story, and I don't think I've heard that specific fear articulated on screen before.
Almost nothing happens in this film's final twenty minutes. It's still the hardest I've had to hold myself together in a theater this year.
The closing sequence — Nora and Hae Sung waiting together, mostly silent, for a rideshare before he leaves for the airport — is the best piece of pure acting I watched all year. Nobody says the thing. Nobody needs to. I sat in my seat through the entire credits sequence afterward, which I almost never do, just to let it settle before walking back out into a very loud subway station.
Sources & further reading
- IMDb listing for Past Lives
- Wikipedia entry for Past Lives
- Official trailer credited to its distributor above; release details cross-checked at time of writing.
Almost nothing happens in the last twenty minutes. It's still the hardest I've had to hold myself together in a theater all year.