Review · Mystery Comedy · 2019

Knives Out

ADM 8/10 Dir. Rian Johnson 130 min No major spoilers

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · Lionsgate

Rian Johnson's Knives Out works as a genuine puzzle-box mystery in the Agatha Christie tradition and as a pointed piece of class satire simultaneously, without either mode undercutting the other. The film's dysfunctional Thrombey family, each entitled in their own specific flavor, gives the whodunit structure real thematic teeth beneath the fun of guessing who did it.

Ana de Armas' Marta, the deceased patriarch's caretaker and the film's actual moral center, anchors the story with a physical tic — she vomits when she lies — that becomes both a clever plot device and a running joke that never wears out its welcome. Her nervous, decent presence against a family circling like vultures gives the film stakes that most whodunits skip past.

Daniel Craig's Benoit Blanc, an exaggerated Southern-accented detective, could have been a one-note gag, but Craig plays him with enough genuine wit and warmth that his interrogation scenes are consistently the film's funniest and sharpest moments, regardless of who's in the room with him.

The film's twist structure rewards close attention rather than punishing casual viewers, revealing its central mechanism about two-thirds through and then spending the remainder showing how the pieces actually fit, which is a genuinely satisfying structural choice for the genre.

Sources & further reading

ADM 8/10

Plays fair with its audience in a way most whodunits don't bother to. Craig's Blanc is funnier than the marketing let on, and the class satire has real teeth underneath the fun.