Review · Body Horror · 2024

The Substance

ADM 8/10 Dir. Coralie Fargeat 141 min Light spoilers, marked

Written by Mara Voss, Staff Critic

Official Trailer · MUBI

I walked out of The Substance and immediately texted a friend "I need to talk about the ending with someone," which is not a text I send often. The premise sounds almost like a Twilight Zone pitch: a black-market drug lets you generate a younger version of yourself, provided you strictly alternate a week in each body. What I wasn't prepared for was how far director Coralie Fargeat is willing to take that premise once the rules start breaking — this is a two-and-a-half-hour film that spends its first hour as sharp satire and its last twenty minutes as something closer to a gore opera, and somehow both halves feel like the same movie.

Demi Moore is the reason the film has any emotional weight underneath all the practical-effects carnage. Her Elisabeth, a fading aerobics-show host fired the moment she turns fifty, plays her own self-loathing like it's a fact of nature rather than a character trait — and there's a scene, her getting ready for a date she then cancels while staring in a mirror, that's more upsetting than anything involving prosthetics later in the film. I didn't expect to feel that scene the way I did.

Margaret Qualley, as the younger "better" self Elisabeth generates, is unsettling in a completely different register — not evil, exactly, but increasingly willing to cannibalize her own source body's time to stay in control. Watching that relationship curdle is the film's real horror, more than any of the makeup effects: self-hatred given a second, hungrier body to live in.

The film's back half isn't subtle, and I don't think it's trying to be. Subtlety was never really on offer here.

Mild spoiler: once the rules get broken, the consequences arrive in a wave of increasingly excessive body horror that I watched half the theater actively recoil from — audible gasps, someone a few rows back walked out. I stayed, and I'd call the final stretch a genuinely gleeful catharsis rather than an indulgence, though I understand completely why some people I've talked to since felt it overstayed its welcome by ten or fifteen minutes. It's not a film I'd recommend on a first date, put it that way.

Sources & further reading

ADM 8/10

Not subtle, and clearly never trying to be. The final twenty minutes will either be the catharsis you've been waiting for or an indulgence that overstays its welcome — I landed on the former.